Do FRAGILE stickers actually help?
Not enough to rely on. The parcel networks are mostly automated: belts, chutes and diverters see barcodes, not warnings. Stickers help the last mile carrier decide which side goes up, and that is worth what they cost, but the packing has to survive rough handling on its own.
Does double boxing actually add much?
It changes what breakage means. In a single box a hard impact reaches the glass; in a double box the outer walls compress, the two inches of cushion absorb the shock, and the piece stays intact. The lost volume costs a small step of dimensional weight and buys a large step of survival.
Is shipping protection worth buying for glass?
For an item worth more than the $100 that USPS Priority Mail and Ground Advantage include, and where you would repurchase or refund on a break, yes. For a cheap vase to a friend, probably not; for a mid-priced lamp base to a buyer, absolutely.
What is the single biggest packing mistake with glass?
Contact with the outer box. Any point of the glass that touches the inner surface of the outer box has a direct path for an impact. Two inches of cushion on every side, immobilized, is the rule. Loose peanuts settle in transit and leave a shoulder exposed.
How much cushioning is enough?
Two inches all around for anything the size of a wine bottle or a dinner plate; three inches for lamps, hurricane vases and heavy pieces. Shake the outer box; the inner contents should not move at all.